What Percentage Of People Favor Family Detention?

3.5 rating based on 188 ratings

Separated children were sent to 121 different detention or care centers in 17 states across the country, often hundreds or thousands of miles away from their parents’ homes. The largest network of child detention centers are the Southwest Key facilities in Arizona, California, and Texas, where 1, 091 (41%) of the children were held. Between fiscal year 2010 to fiscal 2016, there were 2, 362, 966 adults apprehended illegally crossing the Southern border, and 492, 970 were referred for prosecution.

The Children’s Refugee Association (ABA) calls on the government to expeditiously and efficiently reunite families and minimize any further harm to the children. A report by the Women’s Refugee Commission shows that over 99 of participants complied with Immigration and Customs Enforcement check-ins and court hearings. In the past, ICE housed family units containing adult noncitizen parents or legal guardians accompanied by their own juvenile noncitizen children in its Family Units.

In 2022, about 469, 000 people entered prison gates, but people went to jail more than 7 million times. Some have just been arrested and will make bail within hours or days, while many others are too poor to make bail. The 2020 Family Detention data clerk team has made detailed efforts to de-identify over 150 medical record files, and the core team also thanks migrant children and their families.

In the last five to seven years, there has been a movement to improve connections between children and their incarcerated parents, with support from federal and state grants. President Joe Biden stopped the Immigration and Customs Enforcement policy known as family detention shortly after he took office. Detention is only used as a last resort, and capacity reserved exclusively for detaining families increased by an astronomical 3, 400 percent between 2001 and 2016.

In FY 2022, ICE opted to shift its resources again to increase efficiencies in Alternatives to Detention (ATD) enrollment for family units. Over 90% of people are held in privately-run immigrant detention, including those who have lived in the U. S. for decades or parents of U. S. citizens.

Useful Articles on the Topic
ArticleDescriptionSite
Family DetentionRather than providing protection and living up to our ideals, the United States has a history of detaining parents and children seeking asylum in family …detentionwatchnetwork.org
Detaining FamiliesThis report presents findings from the first empirical analysis of asylum adjudication in family detention. Drawing on government data from …americanimmigrationcouncil.org
Alternatives to ICE Detention for Non-Citizens of the United …When noncitizens are apprehended at the border, or within the United States, they can be detained by several federal government agencies …globalrefuge.org

📹 Erin Routon Family Detention and Legal Care

Erin Routon from Harvard University speaks about family detention centers on the US-Mexico border. Erin Routon received her …


Where Do Immigrants Go After Detention Centers
(Image Source: Pixabay.com)

Where Do Immigrants Go After Detention Centers?

Immigrants to the U. S. face a complex detention system managed by ICE, beginning with the placement of a detainer after their arrest for criminal violations. Once individuals complete their prison or jail time, they are transferred to ICE custody. Announcements from the incoming Trump administration suggested a significant expansion of immigrant detention facilities, engaging private prison companies to manage these centers. Immigrants are often separated from those detained in criminal systems and can be held by various government agencies during their immigration proceedings.

Facilities housing detained families, like the South Texas Family Residential Center, have been established. Individuals may also voluntarily leave the U. S. under strict guidelines. The rights groups assert that ICE often detains immigrants for prolonged periods even after winning immigration cases, underscoring the system's challenges. Legislative proposals aimed at expediting deportations have surfaced, indicating a continuing trend in immigration enforcement policies.

Freedom for Immigrants tracks over 200 detention facilities across the U. S., highlighting a predominant detainee population in states like Texas and California. Calls for legislative reforms emphasize the need to reduce reliance on detention, advocating for more humane and cost-effective alternatives. Overall, the current immigration detention system remains a contentious issue.

How Many Illegal Immigrants Are Detained Per Day
(Image Source: Pixabay.com)

How Many Illegal Immigrants Are Detained Per Day?

In FY2023, Congress allocated funding to detain an average of 34, 000 noncitizens daily, costing roughly $2. 9 billion. Currently, ICE is detaining about 30, 003 individuals, marking a significant rise since President Biden took office. While claims suggest nearly 10 million migrants have crossed the border, a substantial number of these encounters involve administrative immigration violations. Arrests by ICE stem from Border Patrol apprehensions and state, local, and federal collaborations.

A 2017 memo from Homeland Security aimed to detain 85, 000 illegal immigrants daily, benefiting private prison companies amidst strict immigration policies. Data reveals that as of 2022, there are approximately 11 million unauthorized immigrants, with about 650, 000 classified as criminal noncitizens on ICE's Non-Detained Docket. Notably, over 13, 000 have homicide convictions but remain outside detention facilities. Since June 2023, the Department of Homeland Security has expelled over 70, 000 individuals.

The growth of immigrant detention has become increasingly evident, with ICE holding 38, 863 as of November 2024. Detention practices vary, but many detained individuals may lack proper documentation or have status issues, highlighting ongoing challenges within the U. S. immigration system. The detention landscape is comprehensively tracked by various organizations.

Who Gets Detained By ICE
(Image Source: Pixabay.com)

Who Gets Detained By ICE?

ICE (U. S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement) utilizes limited detention resources to hold noncitizens to ensure their presence during immigration proceedings or removal from the U. S. This includes individuals subject to mandatory detention as per the Immigration and Nationality Act, or those deemed a public safety risk. ICE often issues detainers against individuals arrested on criminal charges, whom they have probable cause to believe are removable noncitizens, frequently targeting those with prior convictions.

If a family member is detained by ICE, the Online Detainee Locator System (ODLS) can be employed to ascertain their whereabouts, whether they are in an ICE detention facility or a contracted local jail. ICE’s detention is non-punitive and aims to ensure compliance with court appearances during removal proceedings. Upon initial detention by ICE, individuals receive a Notice to Appear (NTA) that initiates their removal process. Alternatives to Detention (ATD) programs are also in place, monitoring numerous families and individuals.

Detainers may be lodged for various criminal offenses, including DWIs or domestic disputes. To locate a detainee, individuals can access the ICE locator to find out if and where someone is being held, as detention may occur across numerous facilities nationwide, sometimes lasting for extended periods.

How Does Detention Affect A Family
(Image Source: Pixabay.com)

How Does Detention Affect A Family?

Detention and deportation have far-reaching multigenerational impacts on families and communities. Families face severe financial distress and emotional trauma due to separation from loved ones, with many struggling to meet basic needs like food. Loss of a family member’s income exacerbates this situation. Research suggests that family support is crucial for reducing recidivism and aiding successful re-entry of incarcerated individuals. Jail time can be particularly hard on families, leading to anxiety and depression, and can push them into financial crises.

Studies indicate that children suffer significantly from family separation, stemming from various causes, including incarceration and deportation. Nearly 80% of families in detention centers express credible fears of persecution upon return to their home countries. This stressful situation can lead to long-term developmental harm in children, causing anxiety, behavioral issues, and academic difficulties. Detained youth are at risk of exploitation and face an environment that stifles their basic needs.

The consequences of detention are further compounded, resulting in increased rates of depression, PTSD, and suicidal ideation among affected children. Overall, the evidence underscores the urgent need for support systems for families navigating these devastating challenges.

What Happens To Your Money If You Get Deported
(Image Source: Pixabay.com)

What Happens To Your Money If You Get Deported?

When facing deportation in the U. S., it's essential to know that any money accumulated during your stay still belongs to you and cannot be seized by the government unless it is tied to criminal activities. The government covers certain expenses, and those on bail won't be returned to detention but may have travel restrictions. Deportation is a legal process for removing a noncitizen due to violations of immigration laws, such as illegal entry or criminal offenses. Despite misconceptions, deportation does not automatically strip individuals of their property rights; you are entitled to your assets, be they tangible or intangible.

If deported, you have time to manage your assets, such as withdrawing funds, closing accounts, or obtaining checks. You typically have around 120 days to make decisions regarding your property, which will remain yours, though managing it may require assistance. In cases of financial obligations or debts, forced sales of properties may occur to settle those debts.

Research indicates that deportation significantly impacts families, particularly within Latino communities, often resulting in increased rates of foreclosure due to the loss of income when the primary earner is removed. Understanding deportation processes, rights, and available assistance can greatly impact affected individuals and families facing these challenges.

How To Get Someone Out Of Ice Detention
(Image Source: Pixabay.com)

How To Get Someone Out Of Ice Detention?

If detained by ICE and eligible for bond, the government will set an initial bond amount, allowing post-release upon payment. If you cannot afford this bond, you can request a bond re-determination hearing with immigration court. To challenge detention or if ICE sets an unaffordable bond, individuals may appeal to an immigration judge for release. Procedures after detention involve ICE enforcement actions, frequently at homes or workplaces. Key steps exist to navigate ICE detention and avoid deportation, inclusive of legal options and rights awareness.

Contact ICE for case status through the ERO Detention Reporting and Information Line or locate detainees via the Online Detainee Locator System (ODLS). Various release pathways exist—parole, bond, humanitarian parole, post-order custody review, or writ of habeas corpus. For assistance, reach out to advocates or lawyers if uncertain about ICE detention status. Detention can occur if an individual is suspected of a crime, leading to an immigration hold. ICE may ask for a 48-hour extension from local jails for custody acquisition. Should you struggle to find a detainee, contacting an ICE ERO field office is advised.

How Many Legal Immigrants Does The US Take In
(Image Source: Pixabay.com)

How Many Legal Immigrants Does The US Take In?

The U. S. Immigration and Nationality Act (INA) regulates immigration policy, allowing up to 675, 000 permanent immigrant visas annually. Approximately 77% of U. S. residents are legal immigrants, which includes naturalized citizens (49%), lawful permanent residents (24%), and temporary residents (4%). Unauthorized immigrants constitute the remaining 23%. By 1919, around 14% of the population had received legal permanent residency since 1900. The U.

S. attracts the highest number of immigrants globally, many of whom seek citizenship, permanent residency, or humanitarian protection. In 2022, over 30 million immigrants participated in the workforce, with lawful immigrants totaling 22. 2 million. The Biden administration's immigration plan focuses on sustainable population levels. Despite claims of an "invasion" at the border, more than 2 million were apprehended for illegal entry, while 1. 1 million were turned away at legal ports.

Legal status data from 2022 show that nearly three-quarters of immigrants in the U. S. were naturalized citizens or lawful residents. California has the highest foreign-born population share at 27. 3%. As of 2023, approximately 47. 8 million immigrants comprise about 14. 3% of the U. S. population. Employment rates for immigrants are slightly higher than anticipated. Legal immigration rebounded in FY 2022, with 2. 6 million legal entries, while citizenship naturalizations approached record highs.

Does Homeland Security Have A Family Detention Program
(Image Source: Pixabay.com)

Does Homeland Security Have A Family Detention Program?

The Department of Homeland Security (DHS) previously operated more humane family detention facilities, offering better compliance with immigration requirements. These facilities house mothers with children while fathers are detained separately. Currently, DHS maintains three family detention centers with a total capacity of about 3, 000 beds. Adults released from DHS custody, often in removal proceedings, might qualify for enrollment in Immigration and Customs Enforcement's (ICE) Alternatives to Detention (ATD) programs, subjected to thorough vetting.

Secretary Alejandro Mayorkas expressed that ICE detention isn't suitable for families. DHS has announced a new ATD Case Management Pilot Program, emphasizing alternatives like ankle monitors and home visits. Despite intentions to align practices with legal standards and enhance family reunification, the DHS has historically detained families in prison-like conditions. Recent discussions suggest a shift away from migrant family detention, as effective alternatives have emerged, recognized as more child-friendly and cost-effective.

The ongoing restructuring aims to ensure families can await assessments outside detention facilities, affirming the department's potential for reform by ending the family detention policy in favor of more supportive measures.

Did The Obama Administration Practice Family Detention
(Image Source: Pixabay.com)

Did The Obama Administration Practice Family Detention?

The Obama administration practiced family detention until a court order prohibited it, with many advocacy groups opposing both family detention and separation, advocating for supervised release instead. While family separations did occur under previous administrations, there was no widespread policy aimed at prosecuting parents to separate them from their children, differentiating it from the Obama policy, which aimed to keep families together. The Obama administration did detain families, but experts indicate that separations were relatively rare, and the intention was to avoid family separation.

This changed under the Trump administration, where the "zero tolerance" policy effectively mandated separations. The Obama administration's approach saw an increase in detaining families, particularly in 2014, with nearly 70, 000 family units detained, but it subsequently released families based on court decisions. The narrative that Obama had a separation policy is misleading; the intent was to keep families together, contrasting with Trump's explicit family separation approach.

While family detention expanded under Obama, it was in response to rising migration. Overall, immigration experts emphasize that Obama's policies, despite some separations, intended to maintain family unity.

How Long Can ICE Hold An Immigrant
(Image Source: Pixabay.com)

How Long Can ICE Hold An Immigrant?

ICE issues a detainer to request that local law enforcement notify them before releasing an individual suspected of violating immigration laws, maintaining custody for up to 48 hours (excluding weekends and holidays). This immigration hold allows ICE to assume custody of the individual, giving them time to initiate deportation proceedings. An ICE detainer, also referred to as an immigration hold, is specifically aimed at individuals who have been arrested for other offenses and are unlawfully present in the U. S. Although some local law enforcement agencies do not comply with ICE requests, those that do will typically hold the immigrant for the specified 48-hour period.

However, if ICE does not take custody within this timeframe, individuals may still remain in local custody for longer, depending on their legal situation. Detained immigrants can face lengthy stays, sometimes averaging over 55 days, with some being held for months or longer if not granted bond. Knowing your rights during encounters with ICE is essential for protection and navigating this complex legal landscape.

Generally, the maximum length of an ICE hold is set at 48 hours, but actual detention durations may vary significantly based on factors such as one's immigration status and compliance from local law enforcement.

Which State Has The Highest Number Of Detained Immigrants
(Image Source: Pixabay.com)

Which State Has The Highest Number Of Detained Immigrants?

Texas leads the U. S. in immigration detainees, with 9, 657 individuals, followed by Louisiana (4, 416) and California (1, 793). Interestingly, states like Arizona, Louisiana, and New Mexico had significant detainee populations in fiscal year 2015 despite having fewer detention facilities than Texas and California. As of June 2023, data shows the highest number of detainees in the nation, reaching nearly 39, 000 individuals. The Global Detention Project identifies the U.

S. as having the largest immigration detention system in the world, with over 200 facilities operated by ICE. Significant increases in detentions have been noted in Georgia, which has seen a 70% rise since 2009. In fiscal year 2025, the Texas Adams County Detention Center recorded the largest average detainee population, peaking at 2, 067. The Biden administration's policies have also impacted detention statistics, but no substantive changes have occurred in Louisiana and Texas, which remain active in detaining immigrants.

States' average daily populations fluctuate, with recent funding provisions for FY2024 allowing detention of 41, 500 individuals at an estimated cost of $3. 4 billion. Overall, the data present a comprehensive view of the U. S. immigration detention landscape and its evolving nature.


📹 Seeking Help for Detained Family 😞🚨 How to Navigate Immigration Detention & Get Support”

In this video, we discuss the steps and resources available for individuals seeking help for their detained family members.


Freya Gardon

Hi, I’m Freya Gardon, a Collaborative Family Lawyer with nearly a decade of experience at the Brisbane Family Law Centre. Over the years, I’ve embraced diverse roles—from lawyer and content writer to automation bot builder and legal product developer—all while maintaining a fresh and empathetic approach to family law. Currently in my final year of Psychology at the University of Wollongong, I’m excited to blend these skills to assist clients in innovative ways. I’m passionate about working with a team that thinks differently, and I bring that same creativity and sincerity to my blog about family law.

About me

Add comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Divorce Readiness Calculator

How emotionally prepared are you for a divorce?
Divorce is an emotional journey. Assess your readiness to face the challenges ahead.

Pin It on Pinterest

We use cookies in order to give you the best possible experience on our website. By continuing to use this site, you agree to our use of cookies.
Accept
Privacy Policy